God on Trial

Staged much like a play, "God on Trial" uses an unconfirmed story -- that doomed Jewish prisoners at Auschwitz put God on trial for abandoning them -- as the jumping-off point for a thoughtful if perhaps unavoidably claustrophobic rumination on religion.

Staged much like a play, "God on Trial" uses an unconfirmed story -- that doomed Jewish prisoners at Auschwitz put God on trial for abandoning them -- as the jumping-off point for a thoughtful if perhaps unavoidably claustrophobic rumination on religion.

Staged much like a play, “God on Trial” uses an unconfirmed story — that doomed Jewish prisoners at Auschwitz put God on trial for abandoning them — as the jumping-off point for a thoughtful if perhaps unavoidably claustrophobic rumination on religion. At its core is the age-old question of how an omnipotent deity could countenance atrocities and suffering. As written by Frank Cottrell Boyce (“Welcome to Sarajevo”), it’s bracing as an intellectual exercise but somewhat half-baked as drama — although just the kind of effort from “Masterpiece,” to its credit, that U.S. audiences aren’t apt to find elsewhere.

Related Stories

The YouTube logo with a crown VIP+

Why YouTube Spending Signals a Changing Content Market

“Sixteen Steps” – As Olympia and Julian get a second shot at a case regarding a tragic death due to contaminated baby formula, their past work on the investigation gives glimpses into what led to their divorce. Also, Matty’s overwhelming stress causes her to consider quitting, on MATLOCK, Thursday, Nov. 14 (9:01-10:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on Paramount+ (live and on demand for Paramount+ with SHOWTIME subscribers, or on demand for Paramount+ Essential subscribers the day after the episode airs)*. Pictured (L-R): Kathy Bates as “Madeline Matlock”. Photo: Sonja Flemming/CBS ©2024 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

'Matlock' Boss on Matty's Quest to Avenge Daughter’s Opioid Death and Almost Getting Busted: 'It Gets Even More Difficult for Her'

The first-rate cast includes Stellan Skarsgard, Stephen Dillane (fresh off “John Adams”), Antony Sher, Rupert Graves and Dominic Cooper as inmates who dare ask whether God has broken his covenant with the Jewish people. It is, clearly, a “trial” to help maintain their humanity in the face of all-consuming inhumanity — keeping their minds sharp as their bodies suffer.

Popular on Variety

The arguments they raise are familiar ones but especially powerful in this context. Is the Holocaust a divine punishment — and if so, Skarsgard’s character Baumgarten muses, “What crime could justify a punishment like this?” Is human free will an explanation? And “If He can do all things,” as another prisoner puts it, “why can’t he purify his people without gassing them?”

In the course of the testimony, several rise to God’s defense, addressing a trio of judges whose verdict is ultimately treated as an afterthought. It’s rather the discussion — as part of the struggle to survive, to maintain sanity — that’s important. (Although described as an original story, author Elie Wiesel explored similar terrain in “The Trial of God,” though there the “trial” follows a pogrom against the Jews in the 17th century.)

Not surprisingly, the tone is unrelentingly grim; director Andy de Emmony and cinematographer Wojciech Szepel shot the piece (in Glasgow) in an appropriately dreary, washed-out manner. It’s hard to escape, though, that this experience feels more ideally suited to the theater, with Boyce devoting such scant time to introducing his characters that they serve as little more than the writer’s surrogates — delivering monologues contemplating how faith can be reconciled with such abominable evil.

Given the dearth of sober theological discussion in the mainstream media, the premise alone merits some celebration. Yet after weighing all the evidence, this favorable judgment on behalf of “God on Trial” falls somewhat short of a unanimous decision.

Jump to Comments

God on Trial

PBS, Sun. Nov. 9, 9 p.m.

  • Production: Filmed in Glasgow by Hat Trick Prods., BBC Scotland and WGBH Boston. A "Masterpiece: Contemporary" presentation. Executive producers, Rebecca Eaton, Anne Mensah, Mark Redhead; producer, Jemma Rodgers; director, Andy de Emmony; writer, Frank Cottrell Boyce;
  • Crew: Camera, Wojciech Szepel; production designer, Mike Gunn; editors, Andrew John McClelland, Eoin McGuirk; music, Norwell and Green; line producer, Hilary Benson; casting, Michelle Guish. RUNNING TIME: 90 MIN.
  • Cast: Akiba - Antony Sher Mordechai - Rupert Graves Moche - Dominic Cooper Baumgarten - Stellan Skarsgard Schmidt - Stephen Dillane Kuhn - Jack Shepherd Idek - Blake Ritson Lieble - Eddie Marsan

More from Variety

Most Popular

Must Read

Sign Up for Variety Newsletters

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Variety Confidential

A Variety and iHeartRadio Podcast

ncG1vNJzZmiukae2psDYZ5qopV9nfXGEjqyanqaVZLqivsqeq6xllprAtbXVmqOsZ5eksW67zWarq6GRoXpyfo9pa3BqZGaDcA%3D%3D

 Share!